Facebook sucks, time to move on

How close are we to admitting that Facebook is just the next Myspace, waiting in line to languish in obscurity and infamy?
I’ll tell you this–it looks like they’re slowballing my updates stream via Twitter. (I have my Facebook Twitter app configured to update my profile.) This could be Twitter API issues, sure, but based on the last few days I think that they may be simply waiting until a tweet is a day old before they put it into my “mini-feed” or “live feed” or whatever stupid name they use to refer to a profile page.
You know, Myspace is backed by vile Australian buccaneer Rupert Murdoch (if you don’t get my reference then you’re not watching enough Keith Olbermann), but Facebook is actually backed by people who are even worse persons in the world than that. Go ahead and research it if you want, there’s no reason to say any more about that one here.
Anyway Facebook’s user experience totally sucks–its photo sharing tools are right out of the 9th circle of hell, its visual design could best be described as DarkBlue Corporate Douche, its recommendation system is worthless, Microsoft is among its shareholders and the loathsome and idiotic Sarah Palin is becoming its highest profile active user.
All that was fine for a while because I would only use Facebook to post links to outside resources hosted on my own web sites and also auto-post an echo of my Twitter stream, and I would log in occasionally to find out what people were up to, because instead of having blogs with RSS feeds that I can read in Google Reader, many people I know (some of them otherwise rational, sane people) have decided to lock their data into a stupid web site where they have very little control over it (remember how Facebook claimed the rights to all photos posted on it for a while until they got caught and “changed” the policy?). But the Twitter auto-post feature acting slowly, perhaps intentionally, is probably the decisive event that turns me off to using Facebook for a while.

The lonely madness of the Twitter user

Love_Fest-SF-2006__CIMG1893

New competitors like Yappd (which so far really isn’t much to speak of at all, by the way) and Pownce are moving fast on Twitter’s market.

After getting a new round of funding in the last month, however, Twitter has started going down again in the last day or two. Sometimes it will work through an app but not through the front page, sometimes nothing loads, it’s all very unpredictable. I am not very pleased about this, as I had started using the service again more.

For now, I’m this close to stopping. But I like Twitter–the bird logos are great for any aviary enthusiast such as myself and the name and constant short sharing of random thoughts, sometimes with people you know and often with others–these are custom designed for someone with my personality.

It could be said that Twitter is a time waster, but that’s not too serious a concern for anyone who could throw off 140 words of the top of his head easily and is using the 140 character text entry field that Twitter allows. It’s very convenient to post to Twitter, and messages have to be short, so normally all I would do would be just pop open a chat window in Gmail or open a widget in Netvibes, type in my quip, and go back to reading my email or checking my feeds.

Once the site stops working, though, the time wasting factor kicks in with a vengeance. I’m checking my profile page to see if it has my latest update. I’m wondering if my hordes of Gmail filters are failing to properly direct tweets from friends when the tweets just aren’t coming in by IM. I log into Facebook to see if tweets are being added to my mini-feed. I go to my web page and it loads slowly as the Twitter updates widget chokes.

None of this should really matter, but for a Twitter addict this can seem a maddening process. The economy of the Twitter message length–the text-messaging-friendly 140 character limit–also imbues those short messages with their own elevated importance in the fevered mind of the Twitter user.

I’ve been using Pownce and Jaiku a bit, and I like them fine, but instead of looking for a real replacement for Twitter I should reach back to my old posts and bring back the idea of being a Qwittr.

Pownce has some really nice features, but what it needs right away is a first-party blog widget and Facebook app, and customized home pages. (Maybe for the pro package at least? Might interest a lot more people.)

It doesn’t seem like many people use Jaiku as their main updates service anymore but it is able to accept RSS feeds from the user’s other sites and that feature seems to have become the key part of Jaiku’s formula–many people, for example, send their Twitter feed to Jaiku so people following them on either get the message, but on the Jaiku feed you might also see the user’s recent Last.fm listens and del.icio.us bookmarks or blog entries. The ongoing stream of the user’s content works much the way a tumbleblog does in practice for many–and an additional feature on Jaiku is the ability to comment and follow others.

Yappd I cannot say very good things about. I just heard about it and decided to try it, and have just found that it does not allow perma-links for individual notes. This is not a good feature, and its lack of widgets and overall Twitter-copy feel did not seem to cover much new territory. Maybe it will add some new features and take off but for now it’s definitely back in the pack.

Yappd doesn’t even allow their vaunted add-a-picture feature for web-based updates, only via email or SMS. Overall it doesn’t seem like a fully developed offering. The pictures are supposed to be their big differentiator, but then recently people like Dave Winer have started using Twitter as a “coral reef” for Flickr photos anyway, so not much at all makes Yappd stand out at the end of the day now. I’ve been looking at some of the debate about whether the market spewing out such lackluster lookalikes is a sign of a financial bubble in the web 2.0 space, and I personally still think it is.

But the latest tulip over-valuation has to come some time, cyclically speaking. The new social and economic phenomenon symbolized by Twitter, however, is generating much discussion on the future of media and telecommunications and gaining broader notice.

My take on all the talk about how shortening the message to 140 characters makes one concise is a very skeptical one, however. People who congratulate themselves for all their great writing just become more appreciative of each of their own words. Yes, in some ways Twitter seems to symbolize the isolation and narcissism that gnaws at the guts of so many titans of tech culture and their copious followers and wannabes.  And it symbolizes a backlash against blogging, yes, the same way tumbleblogging does–for many seem to be relieved of the pressure of producing so many words or managing that sidebar.  And it can symbolize the lonely challenge of the pioneer–many tech early adopters have jumped on Twitter but haven’t yet had many of their friends join in.

Those are all fascinating angles, but I think what Twitter symbolizes is the re-learning of basic PC tasks going on with the techie set because of the popularity of mobile devices from iPhones to Blackberries, Treos and other cell phones to PSPs. Twitter scales blogging back ten years, just as most of those devices take the user interface back about that long.

The file sharing feature is what could matter for Pownce

All sorts of reviews of Pownce, a new service that has been compared to Twitter and Jaiku, have delved into the technical arguments about the Adobe AIR client, and how doesn’t Gmail send 20MB files (to Pownce’s 10MB?), and what does a pro account get you, like no ads (what ads anyway?) and 100MB file sending instead, and usually a review can’t end without an assessment of the clausterphobic world of web2.0 personalites. So I can’t compete with that here but let me add my views on the service:

(1) The single most interesting thing about Pownce is the transparent but almost intangible similarity in feel to Flickr, not a coincidence as Yahoo’s photo service is the de rigeur photo site in the web 2.0 bubble (though still not quite the most popular compared to old Photobucket in what Bob Dylan called “America”). Well the similarity in “pro accounts” stands out of course, (I think $20 to Flickr’s $25–but don’t hold me to that I don’t have a pro account now in either service) but use the web site part of Pownce for a while and see if you don’t also sense a vague similarity in look and feel.

(2) Okay, I will wade a bit into the overall debate–Pownce really is sort of a tumbleblog, but it’s not bad but not amazing, at least so far, and could work a bit like Twitter for some peoeple, and some people could use it more like AOL IM, but it really needs to be able to accept incoming feeds (the way Jaiku or Tumblr can) and have external widgets to give updates from the service on your blog. Also they need to serve up a timeline of public updates. You have to click around to find interesting pages–navigation should be done from more angles. (For now, check lead developer Leah Culver’s page for updates about the service because some of these features or others may be added–it’s in invite-only beta right now and the Adobe AIR desktop client is still in alpha.)

(3) Key among the services mentioned is the file sharing feature. I don’t have to run through the history of P2P networks like Hotline, Napster, IRC, Gnutella, Kazaa and BitTorrent here, but some of their varied histories show the vagaries of both popularity and legality of sharing files on certain networks. Pownce, on the other hand, is a new service that may offer a good deal of privacy because it works off a centralized network. Or it may not. But if it attracts a user base that makes frequent use of the file sharing feature (perhaps even files that are legal to share–if that’s even at all possible under the DMCA–I’m not a lawyer) Pownce could differentiate itself from current crop of both short messaging services and P2P networks.

pownce.jpg

Twitter and Jaiku–which one, and where to now?

I found an interesting article on a PBS blog about the short message service blogs. Basically the writer focuses on Twitter and gives an overall outline.
I think he may have given short shrift to Jaiku, Twitter’s nearest competitor. It is a very cool service as well and actually is a close number two right now in my opinion, with potential to overtake based on how they develop.
I’ve used both services. Check out my pages on the sites:
pacificpelican.jaiku.com
twitter.com/pacificpelican
Since my text messaging on my phone doesn’t usually send out for whatever reason, I like being able to use Twitter for messaging–people that add you as a friend can receive your tweets over their cell phone. So lately I’ve had a lot of fun using Twitter to text message my girlfriend. Twitter also allows updating from a variety of online services like Netvibes and Facebook, and GoogleTalk or AOL IM. I have been using the Twitter Tools WordPress plug-in to cross-post all of my tweets (Twitter messages) on my front page as well as generating “new blog post” when I write a new Diary entry.
Both of these services have been prone to going down or having drops in service levels on either posting public timeline updates and feed updates or in receiving messages from one or more messaging systems. But overall the quality of service has been improving.

Both services allow customized photo backgrounds on user pages, 140 word updates and rss feeds. They both offer “badges,” which are widgets in JavaScript or Flash code that can be put on your Blogger or WordPress or or your Myspace page or wherever you can place code, even your Pageflakes homepage. Don’t make your URL links too long in your messages on Twitter and Jaiku, and don’t use any HTML tags–the former will become a “tinyurl.com” address, which will work but has limitations (like being replaced with a later link you send in another message) and the latter will just appear as ungainly code text on your Twitter page.
Jaiku is a more Euro-centered version, and they are second to Twitter right now I think but they seem to better understand the pure telecom angle in this–getting large numbers of people using either or both of these services could really drive text messaging revenue for telecoms. It’s not surprising that Jaiku is selling a specialized Nokia phone, the S60.
For keeping tabs on what people are saying on the services, you can watch Twittervision 3D and Jaikuvision among many others. Another service in a similar field that I have been using is Tumblr–it’s more of a short blog (“tumbleblog”) than online short message service, which can take a single link or photo as well as a short blog (showing how photos certainly have a place as well in this geo-tagging online mapping/short messages craze–as does the very fascinating Flickrvision)–here’s my page, which mainly uses feeds to track most or all of what I post online:
pacificpelican.tumblr.com
Could these and all the other new messaging platforms all manage carve out their own niche? Twitter is known as the “What are you doing” update service and has a techier feel (for example, reply is done in a “comment on this” blog kind of style on Jaiku whereas it is done by making the @-sign and then the username being responded to the initial word of the tweet) while Jaiku has a slightly better overall web 2.0 feel on the home page. I have no clear preference, but I guess I might start preferring one more than the other depending on who’s using them or which one is more convenient at the moment–for a while I really liked Jaiku, kind of thought I had done the “switch” to it, but lately the range of tools available with Twitter has pulled me back in that direction.

So what is next for the short messaging services? Well here’s one theory. Just as blogs used to be a way for one person to write simple, off the cuff messages to a handful of interested listeners and they have grown into the enormous multi-user data-base-driven CMS-included software packages of today like WordPress, B2evolution and Movable Type, the short message services will expand enormously as they look for ways to grow by incorporating a little feature here and a small one there. What would these changes look like? Well, how about more explicit group setups, allowing people to host their own Jiaku or Twitter powered page (maybe by allowing C-name record based site like Blogger.com and livejournal.com), messaging from more IM platforms (or any in Jaiku’s case), more depth to the home pages in terms of search, features and original content, tagging, and of course, at least one of them should open their source code, or maybe a really cool open source project could be built along those lines. Well, maybe I can get Qwittr out there as one of the attempts.